Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Conclusions

I really enjoyed this project. It was good to get a chance to help someone and to learn along the way. I felt like it brought together a lot of what we learned throughout the semester. Below I make note of some of the most important things I learned from this experience. I tried to put them in some kind of order, but really, they are all important to realize as you try to help people find information.

I would say that the most important part of Searcher-Client relations is attitude or persona. You need to get a reading from what the Client is like from your communication with them. This might be more difficult to do if you are communicating though e-mails but there are subtle clues. How officially do their e-mails look? Do they use emotion-cons or smiles? Do they prefer form style formalized e-mails or do they use slang? All of these things tell you something about the user and help you decided the best way to respond to them so that your communication relationship is stable and effective.

If attitude is the most important part of Searcher-Client relations then feedback is the second. Without a stable Searcher-client relationship we will not get the effective feedback we need to know how to proceed with our searches. That said we need to make it clear to Clients that their feedback is important to us, it is necessary for us to proceed with searches and to recall for them the best results we can find. Part of being a good searcher is always asking the Client on more time, is that what you were looking for or is there something else? And be available, let them know they are not being bothersome if they come back to you with another question.

That said I felt I was fortunate to have a client who I knew I could get in touch with easily. She happens to spend a lot of time online, using instant messaging, checking e-mail, and reading my blog. From this I learned that I must have multiple ways to contact a Client whether it be by fax, e-mail, phone, etc. And despite all that effort on my part, if they don't really want my help then they I won't be able to contact them and that can be very frustrating.

Also, it is important to be clear about when the Client need the information. I found that you need to take into consideration the kind of information being sent, the amount, and there for the time it will take to get to the Client and be looked at. Drawing from personal experience, I know I don't read my mail everyday so it makes sense that everyone else doesn't either. I might be a few days or more before we receive any feed back from our Client.

On that note, sometimes Clients need a push, a reminder e-mail or phone call. Some people are not the best at keeping deadlines, or are not the most organized. It is not our job to organize their lives for them, only to provide the information they ask for in a timely and organized manor ourselves, from then on it is up to the Client and how they want to deal with the information we've provided. They may still blame us for failures, but remember it is not our fault.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Thoughts on My Clients E-mail Response to my Second Search Results

This second search was more successful then my first for several reasons. The more communication I have with my Client the better I understand her information needs. And feedback from the previous search helped me eliminate some search terms while adding new ones, like volcan (truncated to catch all variations of term volcano). Personally I gained new knowledge on the subject which, were I doing this professionally, would help me help Clients who come to me looking for this kind of the information in the future.

I was able to get articles of relevance to my client by the date she gave me. I learned though, that if a client says they need the articles by the 23, you should probably get them to them sooner so they have plenty of time to go over the material. Over all, the search was largely a success because my Client was able to use the articles I found for her to complete her project. And I helped to cut down her work where I could by providing her with proper citations of all the articles, abstracts and full text formats to skim and read in full.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Results of Second Search

The results of this search were much better then my initial search. I now knew not to focus on articles that spoke heavily about biology. However, I could not exclude biology entirely because some layers of sediment are dense with biological diversity and death in the form of fossils making them relevant to geological study. I might have excluded geology related articles had I excluded bio* articles, or marine articles. I will forward an e-mail to my Client, including citations, abstracts and PDFs of the following five sources.

Analysis of Descriptors and Similar Terms

I will add some of these descriptors to my search to bring up those articles that are similar in subject matter and content of the articles my Client found the most useful. I chose to try adding Changes and Stress to my searches. I didn't add or exclude Environmental because it occurs in both relevant and irrelevant sources. Stress is an interesting term because in this case it can refer to plant and animal life, or geological events. These searches did not yield me any new results.

I removed Changes and Stress from my search, they narrowed the search too much, I was only recalling one article. I added volcan*, truncated to find all variations because those two articles mention volcanic activities as an alternative to a meteorite. And I added a different spelling of Permo-Trassic that I had seen, Permian Triassic, since I wanted to be sure to pick up those articles as well. This new search went very well, I got a reasonable number of relevant resources to comb through. I read abstract, descriptors, etc. carefully and picked the best five sources I had found to send to my Client.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Thoughts on My Initial Search

For my inital search I have found 5 articles that I will be sending to my client. I used both Google Scholar and Rutgers Library of Online Databases in my search. Both were useful to me in different ways.

I mostly used Google Scholar to find the titles of supporting articles, but then went to Rutgers Library Online to search the databases for the article since my client requested I proved them with not only the citations but entire articles as well. Google Scholar helped because it allowed me to find articles from multiple databases at Rutgers.

I found that when I excluded the words meteor theory or meteorite the results mostly had to do with volcanic activities. There were also a lot of articles about oceanography and the geology of the ocean floor layers. I even found a few interesting articles about the hypothesis about how the earth goes through 'global carbon cycles'.

I will be typing up an e-mail to send to my Client, including a few articles and asking them to read at least the abstracts and get back to me soon about the relevance of the materials found.

Friday, April 10, 2009

A Closer Look my Client's Responses to My Questionnaire

After getting a response back from my client I took a close look at what she said and was able to summarize it into a quick look sheet that makes note of the important relevant information about my search subject/information inquiry:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

- Information Need/Inquiry: The extinction event at the Permo-Triassic (KT) boundary with a focus on articles that mention the physical extinction of life, NOT the meteor impact theory.

- Type of Information Needed: Scholarly Journal Articles and to a lesser degree of importance, Statistics.

- Where to Look: In databases or including terms like geology, geoscience, environmental science, or geography. Databases are believed to be best for locating this kind of information, though popular articles of relevance can be included.

- When Information is Needed: By or before April 23.

- Prevalent Authority or Authors on the Subject: None known or preferred.

- How will Information be Used: Primarily in a presentation about the Permo-Triassic Boundary due April 23

- Timeliness of Information Publication: Recent or Valid

- How is the Information to be Presented/Provided: Full Articles and their Citations

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

It is important that I keep all of this in mind as I look for information for my Client. I printed this reference sheet and it will help me stay on track and focus my searching. I expect that I may have to make some changes after I provide my Client with a few search results, but through this back-and-forth communication I can learn more about what she really needs/wants and preform better searches.